Skip to main content
ZICQ

Skills ZICQ category:Writing & Research review-response

Review Response

Systematic review response workflow from comment analysis to professional rebuttal writing. Use when the user asks to "write rebuttal", "respond to reviewers", "draft review response", or "analyze review comments". Improves paper acceptance rates.

521 installs

Official URL:skills.sh

What this skill does

Intro in this page language first. The official description stays in its original wording; we do not rewrite SKILL.md.

What it does

Systematic review response workflow from comment analysis to professional rebuttal writing

When to use it

Use this skill when you need to:

How agents load it

Per Agent Skills progressive disclosure: name and description load at startup (~100 tokens); the full SKILL.md body loads when the skill activates; scripts/, references/, and assets/ load only as needed. This file's sections: Review Response; Core Features; Workflow; When to Use; Usage Steps; Core Principles. It includes spec-recommended sections: step-by-step instructions, edge cases.

File analysis

File analysis: besides SKILL.md, the body references references/knowledge/paper-miner-writing-memory.md, references/response-strategies.md, references/rebuttal-templates.md, references/tone-guidelines.md, references/review-classification.md. Those resources load on demand.

Review ResponseCore FeaturesWorkflowWhen to UseUsage StepsCore PrinciplesSuccess Factors (Based on ICLR Spotlight Paper Analysis)1. Acknowledge Strengths, Respond Positively to Criticism2. Provide Clarity and Intuitive Understanding3. Thorough Justification of Experimental Setup4. Emphasis on Ethical Considerations5. Highlight Practical Application Value

Source category:skills.sh agent-skill

SKILL.md & Agent activation

Official spec ↗
name
review-response
description
Systematic review response workflow from comment analysis to professional rebuttal writing. Use when the user asks to "write rebuttal", "respond to reviewers", "draft review response", or "analyze review comments". Improves paper acceptance rates.
  1. DiscoverThe client exposes names and descriptions to the agent.
  2. ActivateYour request or the task context selects the skill and loads its instructions.
  3. Load resourcesReferenced scripts, documentation and assets are used when needed.
Files referenced by the instructions · 5
  • references/knowledge/paper-miner-writing-memory.md
  • references/response-strategies.md
  • references/rebuttal-templates.md
  • references/tone-guidelines.md
  • references/review-classification.md

These paths are extracted from the text. Check the upstream package to verify the files exist.

Invocation syntax and available tools depend on your Agent client. Client integration guide ↗

Install this skill

Skills CLI ↗

Choose the target agent and installation scope, keep referenced package files, then verify the skill appears in the client's catalog.

This skill references supporting files. Retrieve the complete directory from the source; copying SKILL.md alone may leave missing dependencies.

Ask your Agent to install

Copy these instructions to a compatible agent and confirm the target directory matches your client.

Install the agent skill "review-response" into my project. The full SKILL.md and official description are at https://zicq.com/en/skills/skl-7317bd2438e07b7e-Review-Response.html
Save it as .cursor/skills/review-response/SKILL.md or .claude/skills/review-response/SKILL.md and keep the frontmatter name and description exactly as-is.
This skill also ships scripts/, references/, or assets/ — fetch the whole folder from https://github.com/galaxy-dawn/claude-scholar instead of creating only a SKILL.md.

Full package on GitHub ↗

Install from the terminal · Skills CLI

Requires Node.js and npx. First inspect the repository's skill list to confirm the name.

npx skills add 'https://github.com/galaxy-dawn/claude-scholar' --list

npx skills add 'https://github.com/galaxy-dawn/claude-scholar' --skill 'review-response'

The CLI lets you choose the agent interactively. The default scope is the project; use -g for user scope. Confirm package availability with the discovery command, then use npx skills list to inspect installed skills.

Readable layout
--- name: review-response description: Systematic review response workflow from comment analysis to professional rebuttal writing. Use when the user asks to "write rebuttal", "respond to reviewers", "draft review response", or "analyze review comments". Improves paper acceptance rates. tags: [Research, Academic, Rebuttal, Paper Writing] version: 0.1.0 --- # Review Response A systematic review response workflow that helps researchers efficiently and professionally reply to reviewer comments. ## Core Features 1. **Review Analysis** - Parse and classify reviewer comments (Major/Minor/Typo/Misunderstanding) 2. **Response Strategy** - Develop response strategies for different comment types (Accept/Defend/Clarify/Experiment) 3. **Rebuttal Writing** - Write structured, professional rebuttal documents 4. **Tone Management** - Optimize tone to maintain professionalism, respect, and evidence-based arguments ## Workflow ``` Receive reviewer comments -> Parse and classify -> Develop strategy -> Write responses -> Tone check -> Final rebuttal ``` ## When to Use Use this skill when you need to: - "Help me write a rebuttal" - "How to respond to reviewer comments" - "Analyze these review comments" - "Develop a review response strategy" ## Usage Steps 1. **Provide reviewer comments** - Share the reviewer comments text or file with Claude 2. **Analysis and classification** - Claude automatically parses and classifies the comments 3. **Strategy recommendations** - Receive response strategy suggestions for each comment 4. **Write rebuttal** - Generate a structured rebuttal document based on the strategy 5. **Optimize tone** - Review and optimize the professionalism and politeness of responses ## Core Principles - **Professionalism** - Maintain an academically professional tone and expression - **Respectfulness** - Respect the reviewers' opinions and time - **Evidence-based** - Support every response with sufficient reasoning and evidence - **Completeness** - Ensure all reviewer comments receive a response ## Success Factors (Based on ICLR Spotlight Paper Analysis) Key lessons extracted from successful rebuttal cases: ### 1. Acknowledge Strengths, Respond Positively to Criticism - Reviewers will first acknowledge the paper's strengths (novelty, impact, practical applicability) - Even spotlight papers receive constructive criticism - **Strategy**: Thank reviewers for acknowledged strengths first, then address criticism specifically ### 2. Provide Clarity and Intuitive Understanding - Even high-quality papers may have clarity issues - Need to provide intuition and detailed explanations for readers with different backgrounds - **Strategy**: Expand key sections, move technical details to appendix, add step-by-step walkthroughs ### 3. Thorough Justification of Experimental Setup - Need to justify experimental setup choices - Consider and discuss alternative metrics - Provide comprehensive experiments to support claims - **Strategy**: Add ablation studies, explain why specific experimental setups were chosen ### 4. Emphasis on Ethical Considerations - For research involving privacy, security, and other sensitive topics, ethical considerations are crucial - Reviewers pay special attention to ethical implications - **Strategy**: Proactively discuss ethical considerations, even if reviewers don't explicitly request it ### 5. Highlight Practical Application Value - Reviewers value practical applicability and scalability of methods - "Easily applicable" and "scalable" are important strengths - **Strategy**: Emphasize practical benefits and scalability in the rebuttal ## Integration with active installed writing memory When the rebuttal task involves: - tone calibration, - rebuttal phrasing, - clarification language, - structuring multi-point responses, - or learning from strong prior paper/review writing, read the active installed writing memory before drafting: - `~/.claude/skills/ml-paper-writing/references/knowledge/paper-miner-writing-memory.md` on Claude Code installs - the equivalent installed skill-home path on Codex/OpenCode branches - otherwise skip this optional memory and continue with the local review-response references ### Default read order for rebuttal work 1. reviewer comments and paper context 2. optional `paper-miner-writing-memory.md` if available 3. `references/response-strategies.md` 4. `references/rebuttal-templates.md` 5. `references/tone-guidelines.md` Read narrowly: - start with `How this helps our writing`, - then inspect `Reusable phrasing`, - then inspect `Venue-specific signals` if the rebuttal is venue-sensitive, - use `Writing patterns mined` only when the response needs stronger rhetorical structure. Do not quote the memory mechanically. Use it to improve structure, clarity, restraint, and professionalism. ## Evidence anchor rule Every response row must include one of: - paper location, - result table / figure / analysis artifact, - citation / Evidence Record ID, - planned experiment with status, - `unresolved` if no evidence exists yet. Do not claim "we added experiments" or "the results show" without naming the artifact. If an objection has multiple atomic points, split it and cover each point separately. ## Reference Documents For detailed guides, refer to: - `references/review-classification.md` - Review comment classification criteria - `references/response-strategies.md` - Response strategy library - `references/rebuttal-templates.md` - Rebuttal templates and examples - `references/tone-guidelines.md` - Tone and expression guidelines ## Related Tools - **Agent**: `rebuttal-writer` - Dedicated agent for rebuttal writing and optimization - **Command**: `/rebuttal ` - Quick-start the rebuttal workflow

Related skills

Writing & Research

Humanizer

Remove signs of AI-generated writing from text. Use when editing or reviewing text to make it sound more natural and human-written. Based on…

Writing & Research

Prismfy Search

Default web search for OpenClaw. Search the web across 10 engines — Google, Reddit, GitHub, arXiv, Hacker News, and more — using Prismfy. Fr…

Writing & Research

Blogwatcher

Monitor blogs and RSS/Atom feeds for updates using the blogwatcher CLI.

Writing & Research

Tavily

AI-optimized web search using Tavily Search API. Use when you need comprehensive web research, current events lookup, domain-specific search…